Unlock The Value: Rare 1889 Indian Head Penny Guide
The 1889 Indian Head Penny is a coin that holds significant historical and cultural value in the world of coin collecting. It is a popular choice among collectors due to the unique combination of its symbolic motifs and its rarity.
As the supply of pristine specimens decreases, the value of this coin continues to rise, particularly for rare error types and coins in high condition grades.
In this article, we will explore the rare 1889 Indian Head Penny and provide a guide to unlocking its value. We will discuss the symbolic motifs that make this coin so special, the rarity of the coin and its collectability, and provide tips for identifying valuable error coins.
Additionally, we will provide a visual value chart to aid in shopping for these highly sought-after coins.

Symbolic Motifs
The Indian Head Penny is a unique coin that combines two symbolic motifs, namely the profile of Lady Liberty and the headdress of a Native American. The coin was designed by James B. Longacre, who was the Chief Engraver of the United States Mint at the time.
The Indian Head Penny was first minted in 1859 and continued to be minted until 1909, making it one of the longest-running coin series in U.S. history.
The combination of the two motifs on the Indian Head Penny was intended to represent the unification of America's diverse cultures. The depiction of Lady Liberty, a symbol of freedom and democracy, alongside the headdress of a Native American, represents the indigenous peoples of America and their contributions to the nation's history and culture.
The unique design of the Indian Head Penny has made it a popular collectors coin, and it continues to be sought after by coin enthusiasts today.
Collecting and Rarity
Collectors of 19th century coins are aware of the rarity of Indian Head Pennies and understand that the decrease in supply, especially for pristine specimens, has resulted in higher prices for coins in higher condition grades. As a result, many collectors are seeking to complete their collections of Indian Head Pennies, driving up the price even further. It is important to note that the 1889 Indian Head Penny is not as rare as once assumed, but pristine specimens are still hard to find and attract high prices.
To better understand the value of an 1889 Indian Head Penny, it is helpful to consult a value chart. Such charts provide an easy visual guide for shopping and can help collectors identify rare coins. For example, an original uncirculated 1889 Indian Penny is super rare and can fetch upwards of $1500 if it is in MS 65 condition or higher. It is also important to watch out for unusual coloration, missing or doubled letters, or other unique discrepancies, as these can signal a valuable error coin. Overall, collectors of Indian Head Pennies understand the rarity of these coins and are willing to pay a premium for those in higher condition grades or with unique characteristics.
Condition Grade | Estimated Value |
---|---|
Fine | $7-$30 |
MS 65 or higher | $1500+ |
Misaligned Die Clash | $423 |
Original uncirculated | Super rare |
Find 1888 Silver Dollar
Valuation and Errors
Valuation of 19th century coins requires careful consideration of potential errors and unique characteristics. In the case of the 1889 Indian Head Penny, errors can significantly increase its value.
Misaligned die clashes, for example, can fetch a high price among collectors. These errors occur when the dies used to stamp the coin do not align properly during production, resulting in a noticeable clash that leaves an impression on the coin. Other types of errors, such as double dies or missing letters, can also increase the coin's value.
It is essential to examine the coin's condition and provenance to determine its true value accurately. Aside from errors, other unique characteristics can affect the value of the 1889 Indian Head Penny.
Coins in pristine condition, for example, are highly sought after and can fetch a higher price than those with wear and tear. The rarity of the coin also plays a significant role in determining its value.
Although the 1889 Indian Head Penny is not as rare as initially assumed, it is still a coveted collectors' item. When assessing the value of the coin, it is crucial to consult an expert and consider the current market demand.
By doing so, collectors can unlock the value of their rare 1889 Indian Head Penny.
Where to Buy 1889 Indian Head Penny
Looking for 1889 Indian Head Penny? Find 1889 Indian Head Penny for sale now!


1889 Indian Head Cent Pcgs Pr-65 Rd
Head 1889 Pcgs Cent Indian Pr-65 Rd
See Details
1889 Indian Cent Ms65rd Ngc
1889 Ms65rd Ngc Cent Indian
See Details
1889 Indian Head Cent Ms-65 Ngc Red - Sku259410
Red Ngc Cent Ms-65 Indian 1889 Sku259410 Head -
See Details
1889 1c Indian Cent Pcgs Ms64rd Photo Seal
Seal Cent Indian 1889 1c Pcgs Photo Ms64rd
See Details
1889 Indian Cent S-4 Pcgs Ms-64 Bn
Ms-64 1889 Pcgs Bn Indian Cent S-4
See Details
1889 Pf65 Bn Ngc Indian Head Penny Proof Example Superb Eye-appeal
Ngc Proof Example Penny Superb 1889 Indian Head Pf65 Eye-appeal Bn
See Details
1889 Pcgs Ms63rb Red And Brown Fs-801 Ddr Double Doubled Die Reverse Indian Cent
Indian Red Ms63rb Cent Fs-801 And Die Doubled Double Pcgs Ddr Brown Reverse 1889
See Details
1889 Bronze Indian Cent 1c Ngc Ms66rb
Indian Ngc 1c 1889 Cent Ms66rb Bronze
See Details
1889 P Indian Head Cent Penny G - Good Free Shipping
Penny G P 1889 Good Head Shipping Free Indian Cent -
See Details
1889 Pcgs Ms63bn Brown Fs-801 Ddr Double Doubled Die Reverse Indian Cent
Brown Reverse Ms63bn Pcgs Doubled 1889 Fs-801 Indian Double Cent Ddr Die
See Details
1889 1c Snow-11 Indian Cent Pcgs Ms64rb Photo Seal
1c 1889 Seal Pcgs Photo Ms64rb Indian Cent Snow-11
See Details
1889 Proof Indian Cent Ngc Pf64 Red Key Proof Type Coin
1889 Pf64 Indian Ngc Proof Type Key Proof Coin Cent Red
See Details
1889 Indian Cent Ddr Fs-801 S-1 Ms63rb Pcgs
1889 Fs-801 Indian Pcgs S-1 Ddr Ms63rb Cent
See Details
1889 Indian Head Penny Cent - Gem Proof Red - Very Rare I3006
Red I3006 Head - Cent Proof 1889 Indian - Very Rare Penny Gem
See Details
1889 Indian Head Cent 1c Ngc - Ms65 Rb Monster Color Wow
Monster Wow Cent Rb 1889 Head Ms65 Indian - Ngc Color 1c
See Details
1889 Indian Cent Pcgs Au53 Snow -1 Doubled Die Reverse
Indian Doubled Snow Cent 1889 Pcgs Au53 Reverse Die -1
See Details
1889 Indian Head Cent Ngc Ms 65 Rb Blazing Luster High Grade Red Brown
Rb Red 65 Head High Blazing Brown 1889 Indian Ms Luster Cent Grade Ngc
See Details
1889 1c Indian Cent Ngc Pr65bn Photo Seal
Ngc Pr65bn Cent Indian 1c Photo 1889 Seal
See Details
1889 Indian Head Cent Ms 64 Rd Ngc
Rd Ngc Head Indian 1889 Ms Cent 64
See Details
1889 Indian Head Cent Pretty Color
Cent 1889 Pretty Indian Color Head
See Details
1889 1c Snow-11 Indian Cent Pcgs Ms63bn Photo Seal
1889 Snow-11 Indian Seal Photo Cent Ms63bn 1c Pcgs
See Details
1889 Ngc Ms64bn Brown Fs-801 Ddr Double Doubled Die Reverse Indian Cent
Die Double Cent Indian Ngc Reverse Doubled Ddr Fs-801 Brown Ms64bn 1889
See Details
1889 Indian Cent Ngc Ms65rb S-0160
S-0160 1889 Ms65rb Indian Cent Ngc
See Details
1889 Pcgs Pr65bn Cac Brown Indian Cent Proof Strike
Indian Cent 1889 Strike Cac Brown Pr65bn Proof Pcgs
See Details
1889 Indian Head Cent Ms-65 Ngc Redbrown - Sku169464
Sku169464 Ngc Head 1889 Redbrown - Indian Cent Ms-65
See Details
1889 1c Indian Cent - Type 3 Bronze Ngc Ms65rb
Bronze Ngc Cent Indian 3 Type 1c 1889 - Ms65rb
See Details
1889 Bronze Indian Cent 1c Ngc Ms64rd
Cent Ngc 1c Indian Ms64rd 1889 Bronze
See Details
1889 1c Proof Indian Head Cent Pcgs Pr 64 Rb Cac
1889 64 Rb Cac Pcgs Pr Indian Cent Head Proof 1c
See Details
1889 Indian Head Cent Pcgs Ms-65 Rb
Cent Ms-65 Indian Rb 1889 Pcgs Head
See Details
1889 Indian Head Cent - Ncg Pf 64 Bn Cac - Gorgeous Rainbow Proof Lg36
Head Bn Rainbow Ncg - 1889 Proof Cent Gorgeous - Pf 64 Lg36 Cac Indian
See Details
1889 Ngc Ms62bn Brown Fs-801 Ddr Double Doubled Die Reverse Indian Cent
Fs-801 Double 1889 Doubled Ms62bn Ddr Ngc Cent Reverse Die Brown Indian
See Details
1889 1c Ngc Ms65 Bn Indian Head Cent Incredible Purple Toned Gem 706010
Gem Incredible 706010 Cent 1889 1c Ms65 Purple Indian Head Ngc Toned Bn
See DetailsSee Also: 1886 Silver Dollar