Discover The Most Valuable Indian Head Pennies!
Like precious gems hidden within the earth, valuable coins have always fascinated collectors and investors alike. Among these coins, Indian head pennies hold a special place due to their unique design and historical significance.
Just like a well-cut diamond, these coins have distinguishing features that make them stand out from the rest. Discovering the most valuable Indian head pennies can be a thrilling adventure, but it requires careful attention to detail and knowledge of the market.
The Indian head penny was produced by the US Mint from 1859 to 1909 and remains a popular collectible item to this day. The coin features a Native American on the front, facing to the left, and the words 'UNITED STATES OF AMERICA'and 'ONE CENT'on the reverse side.
However, not all Indian head pennies are created equal. Some have unique errors or limited mintages that make them highly sought after by collectors. In this article, we will explore the identification features, values, and tips for buying and selling the most valuable Indian head pennies.

Identification Features
The identification features of Indian Head Pennies are critical in determining their value as highly collectible coins. PCGS, the Professional Coin Grading Service, authenticates these coins, providing assurance of their authenticity and quality. The grading system of PR (proof) and MS (mint state) is used to evaluate their condition, while the mint of origin is indicated by the presence of a P or S in the title. The color of the coin, whether red or brown, is also described to further classify its type.
The value of Indian Head Pennies is also impacted by their rarity. The most valuable coins include the 1877 Indian head penny due to its rarity, the 1888 Indian head penny with the last 8 over 7 as an error coin, and the 1873 Indian head penny with double Liberty, which is extremely rare. The oldest official coin in the series is from 1859, and the 1909 S Indian head penny is also rare because it was minted in San Francisco.
To ensure that one is buying or selling a genuine Indian Head Penny, it is crucial to research the average market price, use resources such as Collector's Weekly and eBay, and provide detailed information and close-up images of key features or areas of damage.
Most Valuable Coins
Coins that fetch the highest prices in the Indian Head Penny series are those that are rare and in perfect or uncirculated condition.
The most valuable coin in the series is the 1877 Indian head penny, which is highly sought after due to its rarity.
Other valuable coins include the 1888 Indian head penny with the last 8 over 7, the 1873 Indian head penny with double Liberty, and the 1864 Indian head penny with L on ribbon, of which only 20 proof coins exist.
To enjoy collecting and investing in Indian head pennies, it is important to research the average market price and use resources such as Collector's Weekly and eBay to stay up-to-date on recent sales.
Providing detailed information and close-up images of key features or areas of damage is also crucial when buying or selling coins. Additionally, it is important to be aware of the different values for coins in good, fine, extremely fine, and uncirculated conditions, as well as the potential for rare versions to still sell for high prices even when damaged.
Finally, it is important to be cautious of fakes and counterfeit coins, as well as to avoid cleaning coins as this can devalue them.
Read about Ike Coin
Buying and Selling Tips
When considering buying or selling Indian head pennies, it is important to conduct research and utilize resources to ensure that fair market prices are obtained. The value of Indian head pennies is impacted by their condition and rarity, with coins in perfect or uncirculated condition fetching the highest prices. It is also important to note that rare versions may still sell for a lot of money even when damaged.
To ensure that you are getting a fair price for an Indian head penny, it is recommended to research the average market price and utilize resources such as Collector's Weekly and eBay. When selling a coin, providing detailed information and close-up images of key features or areas of damage can also help attract potential buyers. Additionally, it is important to be aware of the different values associated with good, fine, extremely fine, and uncirculated conditions. It is also essential to be cautious when buying or selling Indian head pennies, as there are many counterfeit coins in circulation.
Where to Buy Indian Head Penny
Looking for Indian Head Penny? Find Indian Head Penny for sale now!


1901 Indian Cent Ms66rd Pcgs
Cent 1901 Indian Pcgs Ms66rd
See Details
1908-s Pcgs Ms65rd Indian Head Cent
Head 1908-s Cent Ms65rd Pcgs Indian
See Details
1859 Indian Head Cent Ngc Pr-64
Ngc Cent 1859 Indian Pr-64 Head
See Details
1862 Indian Head Cent Pf-65 Ngc - Sku211806
1862 Ngc Cent Pf-65 Head Sku211806 - Indian
See Details
1908-s Indian Head Cent Ms-65 Ngc Cac Redbrown - Sku216806
Ms-65 Ngc Indian - Cac Head Cent 1908-s Redbrown Sku216806
See Details
1866 1c J-456 Copper-nickel Indian Cent Ngc Pr62
Indian Copper-nickel Cent 1c Ngc 1866 J-456 Pr62
See Details
1877 Indian Head Cent Vf 35 Bn Ngc Penny 1c Coin Skui9140
Skui9140 Indian Head Ngc Cent Bn Coin 1c Vf 1877 35 Penny
See Details
1864 Indian Head Cent Copper Nickel Ngc Pf65
Cent Head Nickel Indian Copper Ngc 1864 Pf65
See Details
1884 Indian Cent Pr67rb Pcgs
Cent Pr67rb 1884 Indian Pcgs
See Details
25-full Set Of Indian Head Cent Collection 1857-1909-lot Of 58 Different Coins
Collection Indian 58 Of Cent Coins 25-full 1857-1909-lot Set Head Of Different
See Details
Full Set Of Indian Head Cent Collection 1857-1909-lot Of 60 Different Coins-41
Set Full 1857-1909-lot Coins-41 Cent Of Different Head 60 Collection Indian Of
See Details
1895 Indian Cent Pcgs Ms63rb Fs-303 S-20 Rpd Re-punched Date I
Pcgs S-20 Cent Fs-303 Re-punched Date Indian Rpd 1895 Ms63rb I
See Details
Full Set Of Indian Head Cent Collection 1857-1909-lot Of 58 Different Coins-50
Set Different 1857-1909-lot Full Collection 58 Coins-50 Of Of Head Cent Indian
See Details
Full Set Of Indian Head Cent Collection 1857-1909-lot Of 58 Different Coins-56
Collection Indian Full Of Different 1857-1909-lot Head Set 58 Cent Of Coins-56
See Details
Full Set Of Indian Head Cent Collection 1857-1909-lot Of 58 Different Coins-58
1857-1909-lot Full 58 Of Head Collection Different Coins-58 Cent Indian Of Set
See Details
1909-s Indian Headoak Wreath Rev Cent Certified Ngc Ms 64 Red Brown 1-cent
Certified Cent Headoak 1-cent Ngc 1909-s Indian Brown Wreath Ms Rev 64 Red
See Details
Cac Ngc Ms66 Bn 1865 Fancy 5indian Head Cent
Cent Head 5indian Fancy Ngc Bn 1865 Ms66 Cac
See Details
1857-1909 Flying Eagle Indian Penny Set Dansco With 68 Coins Collection
Dansco Collection Flying Eagle Set Indian 68 Penny 1857-1909 With Coins
See Details
1872 Indian Head Cent Ngc Ms-65 Bn
Head Indian Ms-65 Ngc Bn Cent 1872
See Details
1862 Indian Head Cent Pcgs Ms-66
Pcgs Ms-66 Indian Head Cent 1862
See Details
1871 1c Shallow N Rarest Indian Cent Issue Uncirculated Ms-62 Photoseal Sts
N Cent Photoseal Shallow Sts Rarest Uncirculated 1c 1871 Issue Indian Ms-62
See Details
133-full Set Of Indian Head Cent Collection 1857-1909-lot Of 58 Different Coins
Different Coins Cent Indian Set Head 133-full Of 1857-1909-lot Collection 58 Of
See Details
1863 Indian Head Cent Ngc Ms-66
Head 1863 Ngc Ms-66 Indian Cent
See Details
1908 Indian Head Cent Pcgs Ms-66 Rd Cac
Indian 1908 Cac Rd Cent Head Ms-66 Pcgs
See Details
1886 T-1 Indian Head Cent Pcgs Pr-66 Rb Cac
Pr-66 Indian Cac Cent Rb 1886 Pcgs T-1 Head
See Details
1863 Copper-nickel Indian Cent 1c Ngc Ms66
Copper-nickel Ngc 1c 1863 Indian Ms66 Cent
See Details
1908-s Bronze Indian Cent 1c Ngc Ms65rd
1908-s Ngc Cent 1c Bronze Indian Ms65rd
See DetailsSee Also: Half Dollar